Tol Sirion during its Tol-in-Gaurhoth incarnation, post Lúthien’s victory over Sauron.
Tol Sirion during its…
So it began, the return of the Silmarillion read, slow-cook style.
This is cuisine vastly different from the read-along on the tumblr group. I think of the tumblr read-along as hors d’oeuvre, and this slow-cook as the entrée. Because the Silm does need several passes to “get”.
© Jürgen Heckel
“Before the gates of Angband filth and desolation spread southward for many miles over the wide plain of Ard-galen; but after the coming of the Sun rich grass arose there, and while Angband was besieged and its gates shut there were green things even among the pits and broken rocks before the doors of hell.”
– Quenta Silmarillion, Chapter XIV: Of Beleriand and its Realms
I’ve always been very much on the side of “Thranduil and Legolas had a good relationship” when it comes to their history together, especially given Galadriel’s statement of how Legolas grew up in joy (admittedly that wasn’t in the movies, tho) and, while watching the movies, I was initially wary of how things were portrayed, the closer I looked, the more I’m still firmly on the side of, “Yeah, that little elfling was totally doted on.”
(This is helped by the actors confirming that father and son love each other incredibly deeply, as well as Phillipa Boyen confirmed that, yeah, of course they reconcile between The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings.)
My view on this largely comes from the way they react to each other, even when there’s doubt and hurt and strife there. I mean, this is not the face of an elf who was not encouraged to speak his mind:
No, I’m pretty sure that’s an elf who was brought up to ask questions, to say his thoughts, to have strong convictions. (As well as maybe being a little spoiled, because—well, I’ll get into that.) As well as, when you look at the way Thranduil reacts to Legolas, there is no point at which Thranduil is cruel to him or yells at him or expresses anger towards him, even when he would be justified in doing so. There’s never any, “You sit back down, shut up, and mind your place.”
When Legolas says harsh words to his father, the reaction is instead:
So, I’m going to look at their scenes across the movies and see just what kind of dynamic they really do have. This is entirely movie-based (as it would have to be, of course), so I will be focusing on their personalities and interactions here for this post.
Bravo to myrkvidrs for a detailed look at this. As myrkvidrs postulates in this deep-dive analysis, there is a lot that confirms the relationship between Thranduil and Legolas is not as negative as the initial impression that one gets.
Even though the characterisations serve the scripts, which can be so maddeningly problematic while paying attention to nuances, much of the details and nuance are down to the actors’ ability to convey the emotion and intensity; with all due respect to Orlando Bloom, on Lee Pace’s part in particular.
The pity is that the general audience is not going to spend time studying the nuances, not even if they do see the movies repeatedly. They will, and do, form initial impressions and leave with those initial impressions.
And therein again the rub is while the brilliant portrayal is brilliant, the effort of the talent and the detailed layers crafted is wasted on a big population of the audience. Within the framework of a movie series that has so much going on, some things do need to be DEMONSTRATED overtly. Ironically, despite my gripes about the movies, I do feel this is a case where the common denominator needs to be given consideration and paid attention to. Editing is so tight, and the focus so otherly placed, there is no time for character moments to breath, and this particular relationship suffered, badly.
Did you ever wonder about the Tengwar script adorning the title page of the Silmarillion?
I have. It’s been a little questioning prick in the nape that I know is there, but never got round to assuaging.
Someday, I told myself, I would find out exactly what it said.
Days turned into years, and the world moved on.
Finally, the answer fell into my lap.
Rannoch Moor Reflections by martindavies3
As the icescape signify the enormity that faced Fingolfin at the start of the crossing, perhaps this was the view that greeted Fingolfin at the end of it.
Rannoch Moor Reflections by martindavies3
A Library of Literary Interestingness
Law Student, Amateur Novelist, Suologist, Tolkien Fan, Easily Distracted
to live without regrets
images as thoughts
the quest for the one ring
Exploring Tolkien's Middle-Earth through The Lord of the Rings LCG
A Booster Shot for Relationships
Teacher by day, writer by night...
A place where I deposit my ramblings on fantasy, literature and the world of written word
From The Shire to Mt. Doom... Day-By-Day
Science Fiction & Fantasy News and Information from SF-Fandom.com
Middle-earth dispatches out of the lurkmirk
by Michael Martinez